Cosmos Pizzeria in Southern Shores

5591 N. Croatan Hwy,27949,NC,UNITED STATES
252-261-8388

About

For excellent pizza on the Outer Banks, visit Cosmo's Pizzeria at The Marketplace in Southern Shores. The restaurant prepares authentic New York-style pizza fresh to order, with high-quality ingredients and toppings chosen to suit each guest.

Specialty options include Margarita and BBQ Chicken pizzas, while guests can also build a simpler pie with their preferred toppings. The menu extends beyond pizza to salads, pasta dishes and subs.

Cosmo’s offers domestic and imported beers, plus wine by the bottle or glass. Fountain sodas and bottled drinks are also available. For dessert, the famous cannoli is a sweet-tooth favorite.

Cosmo's Pizzeria welcomes groups looking to enjoy an Outer Banks pizza meal in Southern Shores and is open year-round.

5591 N. Croatan Hwy Southern Shores, NC 27949
252-261-8388

Amenities

Dining

• Lunch
• Dinner

Customer Reviews

Yelp includes 133 customer reviews attributed to Daisy M., Dan M., and Britt S., dated 08/24/2026, 08/20/2026, and 08/06/2026. The reviews discuss how the pizza compares with New York pizza, the convenience of phone ordering and pickup, and Cosmo's Pizzeria as a family pizza-night option after a beach day, including differing preferences for plain cheese and other cheesy or specialty pizzas.