Rusty’s Surf & Turf in Buxton, NC

Rusty’s Surf & Turf
47355 NC Highway 12, Buxton, NC 27920
(252) 995-4184

About Rusty’s Surf & Turf

Located in Buxton, NC, Rusty’s Surf & Turf adds international character to the Hatteras Island dining scene. The restaurant centers its cooking on local seafood and all-natural meats, presented simply while delivering bold flavor.

Owner/chef Rusty Midgett, a Hatteras native, developed his restaurant and kitchen experience at some of Philadelphia’s best restaurants, working alongside top chefs in the industry. His culinary perspective draws from training in French and Italian restaurants and from restaurants he encountered during surf trips.

At his Buxton, NC, restaurant, Chef Rusty favors straightforward presentations touched by international flair. Every dish is prepared with skill and care, with surprising, stimulating flavors served in unpretentious food intended to create an emotional connection with the meal. The menu includes fresh fish, shellfish, all-natural chicken, pork and steaks, pasta and more.

Chef Rusty and his staff bring their heart and soul to both the food and the dining experience, with care and affection evident in every bite.

Dinner is served seven nights a week in-season. Reservations are recommended but not required at this Buxton, NC, restaurant. Although the food is seriously good, the Hatteras restaurant maintains a casual atmosphere with fun, friendly staff, colorful decor and a changing display of local art.

Rusty’s has a full bar serving craft cocktails, craft beer and wine. Guests can dine indoors or outside on the porch. Well-behaved dogs are welcome on the porch, making it one of the few pet-friendly Hatteras restaurants.

Amenities

• Dining
• Dog Friendly (outside only)

Customer Reviews

Yelp shows 332 reviews from diners describing delicious meals, friendly and prompt service, welcoming interactions with Rusty, enjoyable atmosphere, successful reservations and memorable menu selections. The listed reviews are attributed to Chris D. on 04/16/2026, Emily M. on 05/24/2026, and Mary M. on 08/16/2026. One reviewer identifies the orange ginger chicken as a standout and mentions returning to Rusty’s during annual trips to the Outer Banks.