Sugar Shack Fish Market, Oyster Bar and Grill — Seafood in Nags Head

Location and Contact

Sugar Shack Fish Market, Oyster Bar and Grill is listed at 7340 S Virginia Dare Trail,27959,NC,UNITED STATES. The full location is 7340 S Virginia Dare Trail Nags Head, NC 27959.

Phone: 252-441-3888

About

Guests can dine in or take their food home, with seafood prepared to order fresh, steamed, or fried. The menu includes seafood sandwiches, boats, fresh-fried "Shack Chips", seafood sold by the pound, custom-built steamer buckets, and more.

Amenities

Dining

• Lunch
• Dinner
• Gluten Free Options

Customer Reviews

Yelp lists 251 reviews. The featured reviewers are John B. L., Ashleigh B., and Shawn S., with comments touching on repeat visits, rainy-day outdoor seating, She-Crab Soup, shrimp, coleslaw, homemade chips, flounder, and crab spring rolls. The reviews are dated 07/22/2026, 08/26/2026, and 06/23/2026.